Liquidity of Last Resort
A common thread amongst investors and the media at present, is bitcoin’s apparent high correlation to risk assets. Simply eyeballing the data, it looks to be the case for the March 2020 crash, which pushed down asset prices across the board including bitcoin. But it shouldn’t be concluded from this datapoint alone, that bitcoin is a risk asset.
It is true that bitcoin’s correlation to equities has risen in recent years. The chart below, taking trailing 12-month correlation of daily returns, highlights a sharp rise in correlation at the beginning of the COVID crisis in early 2020.
Correlations peaked at a positive 52% to the Nasdaq 100 and MSCI World indices, but have since declined sharply to around 20%, a similar level to gold. Interestingly, this has not impacted the long-term average correlation to equities of 0.04%. It is also worth pointing out that US 10-year treasuries have risen to a 40% correlation against the Nasdaq over the course of 2021, severely threatening the classic 60/40 equity-bond portfolio’s historical diversification merits.
A fair critique of this analysis is that it lacks sufficient nuance. While for most of the time correlation is very low, it is at those crucial periods of market stress where bitcoin’s diversification merits are needed the most. In order to replicate periods of market stress, we have isolated periods where weekly price returns are greater than a 3x standard deviation move in what we define as a “stress event”. For the S&P 500 this has identified 13 stress events since 2013.
The chart above highlights these 13 events for the S&P 500, while overlaying the equivalent stress events for bitcoin prices since 2013. Bitcoin certainly has more stress events than the S&P 500 and to a much greater magnitude due to its volatility. However, the data also highlights that the events between the S&P 500 and bitcoin rarely coincide, indicating that during periods of stress, the assets are not correlated. The March 2020 COVID crisis being the only exception to this pattern.
By isolating the risk asset’s (S&P 500) stress events, we can quantify how bitcoin prices behaved over the same periods. We can also differentiate these events between when prices were rising and when prices were falling.
The data highlights that during stress events, correlations to bitcoin prices rise from 13% to 27% for the S&P 500. Splitting those events into positive and negative momentum events, highlight that bitcoin has its highest correlation during price falls. Incidentally, this is when gold has its highest correlation to bitcoin, this results in some interesting inferences. As we saw during the great financial crisis in 2009, gold fell in-line with risk assets, but this wasn’t due to investors’ fear of falling prices in gold. It was a time of severe liquidity constraints, and gold being one of the only liquid assets prompted investors to sell their holdings to raise cash, which they couldn’t obtain from selling other illiquid assets, thereby helping them fund redemptions or margin calls.
We believe the March 2020 price falls in bitcoin happened for a similar reason, with bitcoin being the liquidity of last resort for the modern age. Bitcoin can undertake this role due to its ability to be traded both during and outside the trading hours of traditional markets, and its speed of settlement compared to traditional markets.
Bitcoin is often compared to tech stocks, but contrary to popular belief, statistics highlight that the Nasdaq has a lower correlation to bitcoin than the S&P 500. Furthermore, a rising Nasdaq does not necessarily mean bitcoin prices will rise as the correlation in positive momentum events are typically negative.
The highest correlation for both positive and negative momentum events is with the Solactive Social Media Index, which includes companies such as Facebook, Tencent, Snap and Alphabet, all companies closely linked to the rising use of the Internet and networking.
As we have written before, bitcoin has a negative correlation to US 10-year treasuries. This negative correlation has become more prevalent in recent years. From this one could infer that bitcoin is a risk asset, however, as we have seen a significant rise in correlation between equities and treasuries over the last year it is difficult to make that conclusion.
While our analysis window began in 2013, bringing the window forwards to the beginning of 2017 had little impact to the overall results. It is also worth considering how bitcoin may behave in a portfolio. Our analysis highlights that since 2015 bitcoin has been much more effective in reducing correlation to the 60/40 equity/bond portfolio than other alternative investments.
In conclusion, the overall correlations are lower than many make them out to be, but during periods of market stress correlations do rise. This is understandable as bitcoin is establishing itself as a store of value with high liquidity, essentially becoming the liquidity of last resort during periods of crisis, rather than being misidentified as a risk asset.
The information contained in this document is for general information only. Nothing in this document should be interpreted as constituting an offer of (or any solicitation in connection with) any investment products or services by any member of the CoinShares Group where it may be illegal to do so. Access to any investment products or services of the CoinShares Group is in all cases subject to the applicable laws and regulations relating thereto.
This document is directed at professional and institutional investors. Investments may go up or down in value and you may lose some or all of the amount invested. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. This document contains historical data. Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and investments may go up and down in value. You cannot invest directly in an index. Fees and expenses have not been included.
Although produced with reasonable care and skill, no representation should be taken as having been given that this document is an exhaustive analysis of all of the considerations which its subject-matter may give rise to.This document fairly represents the opinions and sentiments of CoinShares, as at the date of its issuance but it should be noted that such opinions and sentiments may be revised from time to time, for example in light of experience and further developments, and this document may not necessarily be updated to reflect the same.
The information presented in this document has been developed internally and / or obtained from sources believed to be reliable; however, CoinShares does not guarantee the accuracy, adequacy or completeness of such information. Predictions, opinions and other information contained in this document are subject to change continually and without notice of any kind and may no longer be true after the date indicated. Third party data providers make no warranties or representation of any kind in relation to the use of any of their data in this document. CoinShares does not accept any liability whatsoever for any direct, indirect or consequential loss arising from any use of this document or its contents.
Any forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made, and CoinShares assumes no duty to, and does not undertake, to update forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are subject to numerous assumptions, risks and uncertainties, which change over time. Nothing within this document constitutes (or should be construed as being) investment, legal, tax or other advice. This document should not be used as the basis for any investment decision(s) which a reader thereof may be considering. Any potential investor in digital assets, even if experienced and affluent, is strongly recommended to seek independent financial advice upon the merits of the same in the context of their own unique circumstances.
CoinShares Capital Markets (UK) Limited is an appointed representative of Strata Global Ltd. which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 563834).The address of CoinShares Capital Markets (UK) Limited is Octagon Point, 5 Cheapside, St. Paul’s, London, EC2V 6AA.
The CoinShares Astronaut is a trademark and service mark of CoinShares (Holdings) Limited.
Sign up for our monthly newsletterSubscribe
Our latest insights & research. Never spam.